http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/images/h2/h2_1982.179.29.jpg
http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/works-of-art/10.228.1
Now, i chose these two for the purpose of one drawing. i favor the french, not for the originality but for the color scheme. the french painter, Andre Derain painted a boat with such beautiful colors that pop out so vividly. the colors aren't even "barking at each other" the complement is sync which is amazing.Compare it to the seemingly boring American version. It looks like Andre woke up straight from an acid trip.Yet, i still cant ignore how well and how much care got put into the American Version. How well everything looks to balance each other out. The American version might be quiet and symmetrical, but sometimes you need that. I admire both for the differences and the similarities. The "groovy" tones of the french version and the more strict and on point version of the american. Which either tells me, During WWII, American were more of the "fresh cut" kind of guy, and The French were more "free spirited". This is just all my analysis just from looking and the paintings, dont actually take my word for it.
Good choices for the comparison and on point assessment. Europe (and especially France) was at the center of the art story at that time. America was looking in the direction of europe but definitely showed more conservative attitudes towards their art-making at the time.
ReplyDeleteFor Derain, who was part of the Fauvist movement, the sailing subject matter was an excuse to explore a provocative interaction of color. I totally agree that the colors all work beautifully together despite being so saturated, which shows he was responding to close observations of the actual setting.
American artists were really caught up in showing off the frontier landscape and depicting their society. Homer is a great painter and expresses the moodiness of life on the water powerfully, but is ultimately painting in the service of his subject matter, where Derain uses his subject matter as a springboard to some other territory.
(A)
(Do the cooking project and this weeks blog response, please)